Danny Dislike Banner

ElmerTheGreat2 ElmerTheGreat3 ElmerTheGreat4
Joe E. Brown
Patricia Ellis
Healy High-Hips
Frank McHugh
Released by Warner Brothers | Directed By Mervyn LeRoy

Elmer, the Great: Three Strikes

I have a Facebook friend who is real life friends with French Stewart. I have no idea how this happened. I have no idea if you even know who French Stewart is; I’ve seen Inspector Gadget 2. Stewart is a comedian who has squinty eyes and an oddly measured voice. You may also remember him from the film Love Stinks. Probably not.

I bring up Stewart because his schtick seems to be fairly similar to Joe E. Brown’s own comedic personality. Squinty eyes, big mouth, lackadaisical tone. Not much to it, really. It’s a persona that’s slightly off kilter, like you expect that they have a screen door between them and reality, and only a few bits make it through.

That can be funny when there’s something to push that disconnect, but Elmer the Great does no such thing. Here’s the film’s best joke: “He’s the best ballplayer in the country!” “Hey, and in the city, too!” Oy.

Tell more jokes, Elmer. It can't get much worse.

Tell more jokes, Elmer. It can’t get much worse.

The movie takes place in a fictional world where a baseball team called the Chicago Cubs want to win the World Series and thus acquire talent in hopes of actually doing so. This credibility-stretching setup is compounded by the fact that they hire Elmer, a home run hitting wunderkind who has an ego the size of a ballpark. In spite of that, though, Elmer loves his mother (and the constant stream of pancakes she feeds him), and he dearly loves Nellie, his girlfriend from his old small town.

There’s some dumb bit involving a casino and some betting that goes on, and soon Elmer is in hot water: he has to throw the World Series or else his career will be ruined! But then Nellie pays his debt, so he has to lose the World Series or else she’ll be ruined! But then he bets on the Cubs to win, so he has to win the World Series or else he’ll be ruined!

Elmer the Great isn’t very great, especially for a baseball film. Too much of the time is finding one humorous aspect of Elmer’s character and harping on that: he’s sleepy, here’s him trying to sleep. He’s hungry, here he is continually eating. He’s an egomaniac, here’s how snooty he is to everyone.

Even Sterling Halloway.

Even Sterling Holloway.

The baseball scenes in the film are rare and corny as well. Brown’s natural athleticism is demonstrated by a few hits and fewer scenes of the game being played. Only near the film’s climax when the villainous New York Yankees (boo) use the rainy conditions to fake throwing pitches to Elmer does the game figure into the plot, let alone become exciting. It’s a clever bit of trickery and well played, but it’s also the only real moments of tension or interest in the entire film.

Everyone in this movie is stupid as hell. There are a number of great character actors here– Sterling Holloway! Frank McHugh! Claire Dodd!– all wasted. The rote plot mechanics are funnier than many of its gags.

As a baseball movie, it’s a fairly uninteresting take on the sport– great athlete learns humility. But the methods are cheap writers’ tricks, and the screenplay may as well have been developed along with the sport itself in the late 19th century. Only for those who want to see a cinematic vision of the Cubs actually winning a World Series should check it out, though this movie may be the only thing more ridiculous than that scenario occurring in real life.

Trivia & Links


  • In completely random ‘I’ve watched too many of these things’ news, Evelyn Knapp wears an identical coat and hat during the second half of this film that Joan Blondell dons in Blondie Johnson.
Compare this to the second picture in the Blondie review.

Compare this to the second picture in the Blondie review.

  • Mondo 70 talks about this and the other two famous Joe E. Brown baseball comedies– Fireman, Save My Child and Alibi Ike. They note:

It’s nothing spectacular, but all the Brown baseball pictures are efficiently entertaining comedies maintaining an easy balance of slapstick and character humor. They aren’t exactly among the best comedies of the Thirties, but they’re better than most people are likely to expect.

  • TCMDB has an article about the movie with a few cute stories as well.

Awards, Accolades & Availability

  • This film is shows on TCM every once in a while. And maybe someone has put a copy up over on YouTube at the time of this writing. Who knows!

Comment below or join our email subscription list on the sidebar!

Home | All of Our Reviews | What is Pre-Code?
About the Site | Follow @PreCodeDotCom


Danny is a writer who lives with his lovely wife, adorable children, and geriatric yet yappy dog. He blogs at pre-code.com, a website dedicated to Hollywood films from 1930 to 1934, and can be found on Twitter @PreCodeDotCom.


Le · April 4, 2014 at 3:40 am

I was supposed to wrtie about this… but the video was taken down from YouTube. Yet, I listened to the radio show and laughed a little with Joe E. Brown’s jokes. He’s a funny guy, and what helps him the most in these baseball-themed movies is that he was a great beaseball fan in real life, which is made clear in the radio shows.
Don’t forget to read my contribution to the blogathon! 🙂

    Danny · April 4, 2014 at 3:44 pm

    Looks like I lucked out on getting this one! Well, kind of. I guess I was just more timely on my YouTube watching. 😉 Thanks for coming by, Le!

Andrew · April 4, 2014 at 4:45 am

Hey, what happened to “proof that it’s Pre-Code”? I’d like to know what to look out for!

justjack · April 4, 2014 at 5:01 am

“Proof that it’s Pre-Code?” How about portraying a world where the Cubs winning the World Series was within living memory?

    Danny · April 4, 2014 at 3:51 pm

    Yeah, no ‘Proof’ because this movie’s got nothing. Don’t worry, they’ll be back on Monday.

justjack · April 4, 2014 at 5:03 am

Actually, now that I think on it, I seem to remember a gag from a 3 Stooges short where the Stooges uncover a royal Egyptian tomb, and in the mummy’s sarcophagus was a newspaper. Curly read the headline, which was “Cubs win World Series.”

    Danny · April 4, 2014 at 3:52 pm

    That’s funny! I imagine that there are going to be a lot of sore people if the Cubs don’t win in 2015 as Back to the Future Part II predicted. Even for as outlandish as that movie could be, that prediction was the most garish.

David Inman · April 4, 2014 at 5:49 am

I have to say that except for “Some Like It Hot,” Brown leaves me cold. And I love this: “Everyone in this movie is stupid as hell.” That says it all.

    Danny · April 4, 2014 at 3:53 pm

    Yeah, I’m getting that feeling too. I think it may be a different story if I were a lot younger, but so far he ain’t doing anything for me. Thanks for stopping by, David!

Ted Kierscey · March 8, 2017 at 4:10 pm

Say, all of you naysayers out there in Movie Land. Try making a movie sometime. It’s not an easy deal. And
if you naysayers could pull it off, try making some money with it to pay your expenses back, much less make some
profit on your film. The films you are panning made money in the 30’s because people liked em. It’s easy to sit back and go after things that teams of people created with their talent and hard work. Sure, you’ve got the right to gargle. But try it sometime. I promise not to pan your work after you’re not around anymore. Ted (retired film maker of 44 years)

    Danny · March 24, 2017 at 12:58 pm

    Film making is tough as hell– I’ve tried a few times and (wisely, I think) never shared the end results. A negative review doesn’t dismiss that, it’s just an opinion formulated on the end result. Thanks for what you’re saying.

Comments are closed.