Broadway Thru a Keyhole (1933) Review, with Constance Cummings, Paul Kelly, and Russ Columbo

Indifferent

BroadwayThroughAKeyhole2 BroadwayThroughAKeyhole3 BroadwayThroughAKeyhole4
Joan
Constance Cummings
Frank
Paul Kelly
Clark
Russ Columbo
BroadwayThroughAKeyhole7 BroadwayThroughAKeyhole1Gif BroadwayThroughAKeyhole8
Sybil Smith
Blossom Seeley
Hugh O’Connell
Chuck Haskins
Tex Kaley
Texas Guinan
Released by 20th Century Pictures | Directed by Lowell Sherman
Run time: 91 minutes

Proof That It’s a Pre-Code Film

  • One character, Sybil, is a former burlesque queen, and she acts it.
  • Gold digging – “You never heard of anybody dying from platinum poisoning!”
  • There’s an entire musical number done with women soft shoeing while wearing men’s suits.
  • “That’s the kind of dame I wish you was!” “That’s the kind of dame I was before I met you!”
  • Dance director demands his girls “float over the floor like elves– like Peter Pansies!” The he turns to an effeminate male dancer and admonishes, “Not you, Adolf, just the girls!”
  • “I know a place where that 3-2 beer is 16%!”
  • One musical number features women on scooters with their legs above their head and their crotches flying right at you.

BroadwayThroughAKeyhole21

  • If one stereotype wasn’t enough, there’s also an effeminate interior designer.
  • Sybil seeks an anonymous date. Joan asks, “What’s he look like?” Sybil retorts, “I haven’t the fainted idea. I only hope he’s white!”
  • "You know, he's a hypochondriac!" "Oh, I knew one of them once and was he good!"
    “You know, he’s a hypochondriac!”
    “Oh, I knew one of them once and was he good!”

    “Let’s save our strength for better things.”

  • Cross dressing woman kisses a man, and he worries people nearby might not understand.
  • “Serves you right! Nobody knows you with pants on!”
  • “Where would you suggest I put it?”
  • “It’s my pleasure and my privilege and my honor– what’s left of it…”
  • “Marriage is a wonderful thing, no family should do without it.” “As for me, it’s carrying love a bit too far!”

Broadway Thru a Keyhole: Scandal Under Covers

“Don’t tell me Broadway still gives you a thrill.”

“It always has. And I guess it always will. There’s something about it that gets me. Every time I look at the lights… the theaters… the crowds… Just as if I was looking at it for the first time. They can hock it all they want to, they can call it fickle, gaudy, honkeytonk… but that little gulch out there has got more personality, more character, more life, than any other spot in the whole world. I’m nuts about it.”

Broadway Thru a Keyhole, the second production of the newly-formed 20th Century Pictures, is an amalgamation of two of pre-Code’s most popular tableaus: it’s a gangster film but with musical interludes, all clearly descending from the Warner Bros. model. That’s not a surprise, since 20th Century’s head of production was Daryl Zanuck, fresh from Warners; here he takes what he knew and extrapolates.

BroadwayThroughAKeyhole11

That much is obvious from the opening, a tour down the Great White Way where various people’s boasts and brags are followed by jump cuts to a neon sign for a store that simply sells NUTS. Here’s where we introduced to the omnipresent voice of Walter Winchell, one of the pioneering gossip columnists of the time. He doesn’t appear in the film, but haunts it, his gossip peering in on the characters and greasing the gears of the plot.

The tale follows chorus girl Joan who is helped into her job by gangster Frank Rocci. Rocci is at the head of the poultry protection racket– yes– and in the heat of a rivalry with another mug named Crowley (C. Henry Gordon– boo, hiss). Rocci buys the club from Tex Kaley to spotlight Joan, but then has to send her to Miami when the conflict heats up. There Joan meets and falls hard for a crooner named Clark, who also happens to be a hypochondriac. Rocci gets wind and demands Joan come home, but Clark is smitten and there’s a showdown. It’s a surprisingly emotional one, with Clark simply pouring his heart out and things working out from there. Oh, and there’s a kidnapping at the end, just to add a bit of spice.

BroadwayThroughAKeyhole25

Rocci is played by Paul Kelly, a longtime actor who looks rather shockingly like Josh Brolin. He has a quiet confidence in his manner, certainly playing it with less ham or bravado as many of the other gangster actors of the time, all while letting a little bit of sincerity shine through when he’s unguarded. Unfortunately, he’s the only real strong part of the triangle, as Constance Cummings seems stiff and awkward even when she’s not supposed to be acting that way, and singer Russ Columbo comes across as dopey rather than dashing. (For much of his introduction, his face is fixated in a creepy grin that showcases his teeth in a most unpleasant manner.)

There are a number of musical numbers in the film and even a few slapstick sequences to keep the audience awake. It and much of the film play like a smorgasbord of early 30s films. Besides the Warner gangster flicks, you have “The Uptown Lowdown” with a dozen girls tap dancing in tails like a Marlene Dietrich fever dream. Several of the other numbers, like “The Girl on the Scooter and You Were the Boy on the Bike”, have a decidedly Busby Berkeley bent, featuring geometric shapes and scantily clad dancers deftly handling their large globes. (Not an innuendo.)

BroadwayThroughAKeyhole35

The supporting cast is a lot more fun, with Tex Guinan playing a burlesque of herself which isn’t that far off from Mae West’s schtick. Sybil Smith as the lecherous former burlesque queen who cross dresses to mess with her dimwitted gangster boyfriend is clearly having a ball even in the film’s darker parts, and Hobart Cavanaugh, playing the appropriately named Peanuts Dinwiddie, is also a lot of fun.

Broadway Thru a Keyhole really packs in a lot, but it never really seems to draw things together in a way that’s wholly satisfactory between the darker gangster film and the revue portions. Undone by a few weak leads, it remains a well made if off the mark movie.

Gallery

Click to enlarge. All of my images are taken by me– please feel free to reuse with credit!

Trivia & Links

  • Russ Columbo, Tex Guinan and director Lowell Sherman would all be dead within a year and a half of this film’s premiere. Columbo died in a freak accident with an antique gun, Guinan contracted dysentery, and Sherman came down with pneumonia.
  • A very young, very blonde Lucille Ball gets one line in the film. Ann Sothern is also in here as a chorus girl somewhere, though I missed her.
I <3 Lucy (bit parts).
I <3 Lucy bit parts.
  • TCMDB talks about the film’s rather spurious origins:

Broadway insiders recognized the film’s story as based on a real-life romantic triangle that had played out a few years earlier between dancer Ruby Keeler, entertainer Al Jolson (who married Keeler in 1928), and mobster Larry Fay, who had reportedly been romantically involved with Keeler during her Broadway days. Shortly before Broadway Thru a Keyhole began production, Jolson ran into Winchell at a boxing match and punched him, citing reports about the forthcoming film as the reason. Winchell was quoted in the press as suggesting that Jolson should play the lead in the film himself. The real-life Fay had been shot and killed by a disgruntled employee the previous New Year’s Eve.

  • In that spirit, Mondo 70 compares this film to the Keeler/Jolson musical Go Into Your Dance, citing both as derivative of Berkeley while presaging film noir.

Awards, Accolades & Availability

  • This film is an obscure one– I caught it on TCM recently. There is a copy on YouTube, but it’s missing about 5 minutes. I wish you luck in finding it!

More Pre-Code to Explore

WhatIsPreCode2 FilmList
ImageBumper

Actresses Actors
ImageBumper

Timeline Twitter
 

Danny

Danny is a librarian who lives on the coast of California with his lovely wife, adorable daughter, and yappy dog. He blogs bi-weekly at pre-code.com, a website dedicated to Hollywood films from 1930 to 1934, and can be found on Twitter @PreCodeDotCom.

2 thoughts on “Broadway Thru a Keyhole (1933) Review, with Constance Cummings, Paul Kelly, and Russ Columbo

    1. That’s not Ann Sothern in the scene with Lucy. Ann allegedly filmed a number under her real name, Harriette Lake, but it was cut. She was in LA on the west coast tour of the Gershwin musical Of Thee I Sing. Sothern did however have a bit part in the Shanghai Lil number in Footlight Parade. She signed to Columbia Pictures not too long after that.

Leave a Reply!