Goldie (1931) Review, with Jean Harlow and Spencer Tracy

Indifferent

Goldie3 Goldie15 Goldie19
Spike
Warren Hymer
Bill
Spencer Tracy
Goldie
Jean Harlow
Released by Fox Films | Directed by Benjamin Stoloff
Run time: 68 minutes (Viewed print: 60)

Proof That It’s a Pre-Code Film

  • Two sailors go to a fashion show where Tracy insists, “The more you clap, the more they take off!” And I’ll be damned if it doesn’t seem to work.
  • “I didn’t know you with so many clothes on!”
  • From AFI, this film may be the first sound picture where the word “tramp” is used (and it’s definitely used more than once).
  • “She knows all about sailors.”
    “I’ll say she knows all about sailors!”
  • There are a number of bar fights, one resulting from Tracy insulting a prostitute who rolls drunken sailors.

Goldie: Two Sailors and a Golden Girl

“I know lots of girls who make an honest living doing the wrong thing!”

Goldie is kind of a weird duck, a combination of two distinct threads of films being made in early 1930s Hollywood. One is the “Spencer Tracy plays a smug jerk with a secret heart of gold” series of pictures, and the other is “Jean Harlow is a sexual monster whom no man can stop.”

Both of these genres work together fine, and both work together in the expected pre-Code way– someone shows plenty of skin and someone gets a sock in the nose– and neither of them are Tracy. But there’s not much here that you ain’t seen elsewhere, and much of it depends on your tolerance level for Warren Hymer’s dumb schmoe routine (at one point, he tries to throw out caviar because it looks like tapioca but smells like dead fish.)

Blonde and Dumber
Blonde and Dumber

Using two sailors as the protagonists allows the movie to really go for gusto in its sexual proclivities. Tracy’s character, Bill, has a fondness on tattooing his girls with a particular heart and anchor design to demonstrate some level of perverse ownership. These are also the same women that Spike (Hymer) is trying to track down, and the first half of this movie is one scene after another of Spike finding the mark on women all over the globe and throwing down his hat in frustration. Spike finally learns that Bill is the man who’s been getting in his way, so the two fight it out until they become fast friends.

They’re living together and everything is grand until Goldie (Harlow, naturally), a stunt diver at the local circus (and another prior lover of Bill’s) drops in on them. Goldie is only out to shake Spike out of every cent he owns, and Bill knows if he interferes, Spike will learn of his and Goldie’s past and get sore, so to speak. Goldie is all but rolling her eyes as Hymer hands her dollar after dollar, and Tracy wrings his heart out to the screen– weird way to make a comedy.

Frustrated and Blonder
Frustrated and Blonder

All of the women shown here are performers, prostitutes, widows, or widows while their husbands are away. Considering there’s also a scene where Harlow fakes being raped by Bill in order to infuriate Spike, this isn’t exactly The Feminine Mystique. Hell, it’s barely a step above The Swingin’ Cheerleaders in its depiction of women.

That makes Goldie not so much a story of two men who have to guard each other from vicious women, but the question in how they must constantly guard against their own stupidity when it comes to a pair of pretty eyes. This is another film that makes the men out as scared little children who scamper into sexual escapades but become overwhelmed when real emotions enter the picture. And the less said about the euphemistic tendency for Bill’s middle finger to break in a fight and Spike needing to delicately pop it back in its socket, the better.

Most of my screenshots are either impossible to see or, well, barely dressed.
Most of my screenshots are either impossible to see or, well, barely dressed.

I suppose in the end, my recommendation on this film doesn’t mean a whole lot at the moment; I was only able to see it because the fabulous and all-around great Karen at Shadows and Satin gave me a copy on a burned DVD. This copy is a transfer of a VHS recording of someone videotaping a screening of the film who-knows-how-long-ago. Frankly, it’s a Fox Film, so the fact I was able to get a hold of the movie at all, which I’ve been seeking out for some years, is still pretty great.

That makes this, in its current state, an item of curiosity just as much as it is a film. I can’t imagine a Spencer Tracy expending much effort on this one, since this role is exactly what he was doing again and again at the time. And I can’t imagine anyone seeking out the entire filmography of Warren Hymer. I just can’t.

Unless they're making a good dollar off of it, of course.
Unless they’re making a good dollar off of it, of course.

The real curiosity then is Jean Harlow. This film can probably be considered the nadir of her film career, coming after roles in Iron Man and The Public Enemy that showcased her stunning looks but left her looking awkward in the acting department– she didn’t have an ounce of naturalness in either of them. This film came before she did a few excellent pictures at Columbia, Platinum Blonde and Three Wise GirlsGoldie sits in an awkward middle; Harlow doesn’t show up until the halfway mark, and there’s no color to the character. She’s just despicable through and through. But Harlow still brings something to it, a cool nastiness that radiates, and its a few decibels closer to witty rather than shrill than her previous turns. There are still a few theatrics that would need to be ironed out, but Harlow needed better parts at this point more than anything.

If you take the time to find Goldie, it may be good for a late night watch. If it’s showing at a festival or if Fox every manages to release it on home video (shortly after hell freezes over, I’m sure), its rarity is reason enough to see it. But it’s a movie you’re seeing for what its stars would become rather than for anything they were at the time.

Gallery

Click to enlarge. All of my images are taken by me– please feel free to reuse with credit!

Trivia & Links

  • The first of three films that Spencer Tracy and Jean Harlow made together. The two others, Libeled Lady and Riffraff, were released when both were much more established stars in 1936.
  • A remake of the 1928 film A Girl in Every Port, which starred Robert Armstrong and Victor McLaglen and, in the Harlow part… Louise Brooks. Man, now I want to watch that one.
  • According to IMDB, George Raft is in here in a bit part as a pickpocket. Honestly, I didn’t even see him.

According to the MPAA/PCA Collection at the AMPAS Library, producer A. L. Rockett agreed to make two changes in the film, after it was submitted to the Hays Office, to conform to the requirements of the Production Code. These involved some lines uttered by “Spike” before he looks through a keyhole at a woman in a bathtub which made clear that he had been involved with the woman in the past (apparently the scene without the lines was supposed to imply that Spike’s peeping through the keyhole was unpremeditated); and shots of a woman “dancing the hootch” at the carnival scene. Rockett, however, left in the film four items which the Hays Office warned could be considered objectionable by the various censor boards. When Twentieth Century-Fox attempted to get a certificate for the film’s reissue in 1937, Joseph Breen wrote that the film “raised a storm of protest” when it was first released because of its “vulgarity and low moral tone.”

  • Mordaunt Hall in the Times barely spends three paragraphs on this offering, noting “it offers an air-cooled and otherwise pleasant enough respite from the outer heat.” But, he wryly adds, “The most spectacular feat in the picture is Miss Harlow’s, who is supposed to perform a 200-foot dive and emerges without wetting her hair or disturbing her face powder.”

Awards, Accolades & Availability

  • This film is a (really) obscure one. I wish you luck in finding it!

More Pre-Code to Explore

WhatIsPreCode2 FilmList
ImageBumper

Actresses Actors
ImageBumper

Timeline Twitter
 

Danny

Danny is a librarian who lives on the coast of California with his lovely wife, adorable daughter, and yappy dog. He blogs bi-weekly at pre-code.com, a website dedicated to Hollywood films from 1930 to 1934, and can be found on Twitter @PreCodeDotCom.

8 thoughts on “Goldie (1931) Review, with Jean Harlow and Spencer Tracy

  1. I saw “A Girl in Every Port” lo-o-o-ng ago. I do remember that Brooks was spectacular, almost instinctual, and that the two male characters were as dumb as in the remake. The theme of “a dame coming between two guys” has become more offensive as the years drag on.

  2. I would love to eventually get my hands on this! I’m a massive Jean Harlow and Spencer Tracy fan, so the fact this film stars both of them and is ultra-rare has me very much intrigued.

  3. Meet the founder of the Warren Hymer Fan Club :). Warren and Tracy were a big hit in John Ford’s “Up the River” the previous year. Fox wanted them to be the new Edmund Lowe and Victor McLaglen of the Quirt and Flagg mold from “What Price Glory?” and its subsequent sequels, therefore “Goldie” was put into production. Warren did not stay at Fox long afterward so this idea was not to be realized and perhaps for the better. He was a very underrated character actor and unfortunately “Goldie” was not the best vehicle to show his talent and the same can be said for Tracy and Harlow as well. As for his filmography, there are many films pre and post-code where he gave very good to great performances, several of which you’ve reviewed on this very site.

  4. I’m the one that videotaped it from a movie theater in Manhattan. I believe it was around 1992. I wish that they’d release this on DVD!

  5. Haven’t seen this one but Jean Harlow always fun! She wasn’t much to look at (called her hideous when I image googled her before seeing her in anything! Pudgy face, thick vulgar features, dead eyes) however her “truck driver in a white evening gown” personality shines!

    T her best in Clark Gable films IMHO. SPEAKING OF WHICH…

    1-I canNOT find a search button on this s ite but maybe it’s my ancient device’s obsolete browser? So I don’t know if you have a page on this uber-rare film:

    2-NIGHT FLIGHT with Gable, Loy, b oth Barrymores and Helen Hayes. Could one one please TAPE it and UPLOAD at archive.org pleeeease?? It’s airing for a very rare time in a few hours (1:30 pm PST 4:30pm EST) on TCM TODAY!!!!

    I NEED to watch this, I’m begging you please grab it, DVR it and share in pristine HQ. thanks in advance.

    It’s supposed to be full but it is a very unusual film, recommended to all aviation fans. It’s a pre-Tet Pilot (w Loy & Gable) flick and was shamelessly remade, arson me, RIPPED OFF, and remade as a dull Cary Grant vehicle called Angels omething or another.

    Anyway, if someone doesn’t grab this film off TCM today, there’s a huge chance all DVDs out there will be remotely erased today by a mad scientist (trust me!) Kindle 1984 style and we will all die of syphillis, SARS and swine flu combo created by said scientist and shot in the air above where you live. Don’t ask me how I know this, Jean Harlow rocks and upload Night Flight t Archive dot org before midnight today or the sun will go supernova at midnight courtesy of Roxor’s death ray, trust me.

    Thanks for saving the planet, Bat-man!

  6. ^^^mad keyboard corrections:
    -Someone (not one one LOL!)
    -supposed to be DULL, not ful
    -AT her best
    -TEST pilot
    -PARDON me (please DONT arson me, dafooq?)

    The rest is all true, don’t risk it!
    Cpacuba! (that’s Russian for Spasiba!)
    l

  7. Only Angels Have Wings is the 1939 Night Flight rip off. Stars the ever uber-dull, wooden Cary Grant, and grab your earplugs cos the screechingly annoying voice of Jean Arthur is there too attached to the rest of her oh and for those who like her, a very young Rita Hayworth in a bit part struts her goods.

    That’s why you need Night Flight! Don’t settle for cheap copies with a dullard when you can have the bizarro original. Helen Hayes pines over a framed Clark Gable 8×10 and hammies it up in some weirdo scenes. This film is literally out of this world, those flight scenes… Enough said. If you die and get to heaven before watching NF, you will kill yourself when St Peter shows you a clip of what you missed! (it’s not anywhere online, trust me, I been everywhere, got the 1400 viruses to prove it!)

    Thanks Bro, much obliged.

  8. I’m so glad you were able to watch it, Danny — loved your review! I have to be honest and admit that I have never made it all the way through Goldie. It’s just too goofy. It’s totally worth it for Harlow, though.

Leave a Reply!